Open Thou Our Lips

Living the Book of Common Prayer

Tuesday, November 01, 2005

Breathing the Psalms

This is an initial foray into constructing a curriculum on Psalmody and the Daily Office. Comments and criticisms of all sorts are appreciated...

The traditional monastic practice of chanted psalmody--inherited by the Anglican tradition--is a form of breath meditation. That is, the psalms are read in such a way that the text corresponds to the breath, particularly deep, elongated breathing that assists the body in falling into a restful receptive state enabling deep contemplation of the texts. First, I shall discuss the traditional technique for breathing the psalm used for congregational singing and speaking of the Psalter. Second, I shall discuss how these breathing techniques may be adapted for solo use, either in reading the psalms aloud or silently. (Note: Anything that I say about the psalms here is also directly applicable to the canticles of the Church.)

Singing the Psalms
The traditional Gregorian chant of the Western Church uses nine psalm tones: eight correspond to the eight modes, the last is a tonus peregrinus (see below). Even if you do not sing the psalms on a regular basis, it is important to know the structure of the process because it influences how the psalms are read aloud communally.

Parts of the Psalm Tone
The typical psalm tone has six parts. The first part is called the incipit and typically contains two or three notes that move in an upward direction. When a psalm is being sung, the incipit is only used at the very beginning of the psalm or when psalm verses begin again after an antiphon. (Gospel canticles are different in that the incipit is sung at the beginning of each verse.)

The second part is the reciting tone. This is a note on which the majority of the psalm verse is sung. The psalm is recited on this note until it hits one of the next two parts.

The third part is the flex. This is a single note which drops either a second or a third. In the case of a psalm verse with a long first half, the flex is used as a brief break along the choir to catch a quick breath before returning again to the reciting tone. If, in the BCP's printing, a psalm verse goes to a new full line before the asterisk, a flex would be used (E.g. Ps 1:3; 2:2, but not Ps 1:1, 5; 2:8 because the line break does not start a full line).

The fourth part is the mediant. The mediant comes shortly before the asterisk which marks the middle of the psalm verse. The exact distance from the asterisk depends on the number of stressed syllables in the final words; the required number varies by psalm tone.

The fifth part is actually the reciting tone again. In the eight psalm tones that correspond with the eight modes, this reciting tone is exactly the same as the first reciting tone. Tonus peregrinus, the ninth tone, which means "wandering tone" has a different reciting tone in the second half than in the first half.

Note that there is no equivalent to the flex in the second half of the psalm verse. For instance, you might expect the equivalent of a flex at the end of the second line in Ps 1:1—but there is no such part.

The sixth part is the final cadence. Like the mediant, when it begins in the last line of the psalm is based on the number and placement of stressed syllables in relation to the psalm tone itself.

Communal Psalmody
Communal Chanting
Chanting the psalms in the traditional manner attends to breath. One designated person--the cantor--begins the psalm and sings from the incipit to the first mediant alone. Then, the rest of the congregation joins in on the last half of the verse. From that point, the two sides (facing each other in a traditional choir set-up) alternate verses.

As one side comes the end of a verse, the other side inhales, preparing to take up the next verse. As the verse ends, the other side picks it up smoothly, leaving no break or gap between the two. If the verse does not directly follow an antiphon, the verse begins directly on the reciting tone. Singing, clearly, expends the breath that the side had taken before the verse started. If there is a flex, the side snatches a quick catch breath before continuing on.

By the time the side reaches the mediant, there is not much breath left. There is a significant pause at the mediant because at the point the side exhales the remaining breath, then inhales a full new breath. As a community or a new person begins singing the psalms in this way the break—which may last five, six beats or even longer—will seem too long. Resist the temptation to rush; take the time to breathe.

With a full new breath in their lungs, the side then comes to the end of the verse and exhales the remaining breath after the final cadence. The other side then smoothly moves to the next verse.

Communal Speaking
Speaking the psalms in community follows essentially the same pattern. The mechanics of the breath work in exactly the same way. Because speaking requires less breath-control than singing, the urge to rush the breathing pause at the mediant is greater. Again, resist the urge.

Individual Psalmody
Individual Chanting
If you chant the psalms by yourself, the pattern is basically the same as singing them communally. The difference is that at the end of every other verse there is no alternate side to begin where you leave off. As a result, the end of each line must be treated in the same manner as the mediant. Exhale all of the breath left in your lungs and breathe in a new breath. Then continue on to the next verse.

Reading AloudIf you are reading the psalms aloud by yourself, the pattern again follows that of singing. Take a full breath, read to the asterisk/mediant, exhale, breathe in a new breath, then read the second half of the verse. Exhale again, inhale, then start the next verse. If a flex occurs, grab a quick catch breath.

Reading Silently
Reading silently is the only form of reading that is not fundamentally based on the communal singing pattern. Basically, the difference between reading silently and reading or singing aloud is that no breath is expended in the process. As a result, exhalations and inhalations must be balanced differently. The best way to proceed is to simply alternate half-verses. Inhale slowly as you silently read to the mediant; exhale slowly as you read to the end of the verse.

Conclusion
Following these directions for encountering the psalms will accomplish several things. First, tying the psalms to the breath forces you to slow your reading pace and to pay more attention to what you are reading. It is easy to let the words flow beneath your eyes and for the attention to wander. Tying the text to the breath will make you read more slowly even if you are reading silently (when you are more prone to rush).

Second, tying the two together also slows down and regulates your breathing. Regulation of the breathing is regulation of the whole body. The slower, deeper breaths will encourage a meditative state of mind that will enable you to relax and concentrate more completely on the text. The more you concentrate, the more your mind retains and passively memorizes.

Third, when read or sung in community, following the breath will tie the whole community together in closer harmony. Listening and being attentive to the breath patterns of those around you so that you begin and end the mediant pauses at the same time will yoke the community closer together in common prayer. There is an indescribable harmony that accompanies a non-anxious attention to the communities breath--a true discerning of the spirit that moves within the gathered people at prayer.

23Comments:

At Tuesday, November 01, 2005 5:29:00 PM, Blogger bls said...

Wonderful!

What I want to do now is put up some sound files of sung Psalms, and images of some of the tones, so people can get the idea of how this all goes. (Or, we could recommend they get a copy of "Guard Us Sleeping," the Compline service by SSJE.)

I also have another project in mind. I want to gather all the monastic hymns I can find and put them together in a volume so that people can learn them. The service goes in a particular way - certain Psalms on certain days, and always including a Canticle and a hymn - and I like singing it this way myself, even alone. (I sing in the car on the way to work.) There are many really wonderful - and very ancient - hymns.

My other plan is to make a comprehensive list of all monastic communities - Catholic, Episcopal, and Orthodox - in the United States, so people could have a chance to hear what this all sounds and feels like. (You get a pretty good idea on the SSJE disk.) It takes awhile to get used to it all.

The last thing we need is an intro to Psalms as texts. People aren't used to the imagery in them anymore, I don't think, and some context would be very helpful.

 
At Wednesday, November 02, 2005 11:44:00 AM, Blogger Derek the Ænglican said...

Images shouldn't be a problem thanks to the Gregorian software.

Sound files gets a little more complicated although you've got the music contacts to make some if need be...


I'm not sure where you're going with the comprehensive monastic list, though

 
At Wednesday, November 02, 2005 2:16:00 PM, Blogger bls said...

Oops, I was just blathering on there. I've just noticed that if you want to find a service of Divine Office to attend, you have to look under the various orders separately, and who knows what they all are?

I just wanted to make a central website or blog where all these things could be listed together.

Sorry for the digression. This is a great article and it got me thinking, that's all....

 
At Wednesday, November 02, 2005 2:26:00 PM, Blogger LutherPunk said...

Derek - I like the how-to nature of this post. I wish there was something online like this years ago when I was searching for "how to do" Christian practice. Great post!

 
At Wednesday, November 02, 2005 2:36:00 PM, Blogger Derek the Ænglican said...

Thanks, lp--that was my idea. I've never seen a good how-to on these sorts of things so I thought I'd just write it up... :-) My concern is those inevitable "things that go unsaid"--the things that are so obvious to me that I don't see the need to say them but if someone who doesn't know them tries to do it, it won't work. (Know what I'm saying?)

 
At Wednesday, November 02, 2005 4:50:00 PM, Blogger *Christopher said...

derek, this is simply glorious (to echo caelius). I have to echo what lp said. Would you consider publishing a "how to" with simple psalm tones on disc? The reason I say this is not everyone can read music, but many can figure out how to do the chant if tones are provided with examples. That's how I learned after all. And I understand the BCP tones are on disk for this type of practice.

What is Gregorian software? Is this something I need?

bls, please do post those tones (I know there are also Gregorian tones on-line for free use). I'll add those later.

I feel like a real dunce for not actually being able to read music well considering my area of study. I think a remedial course with Dr. Weil is in order next year on basic chant. What I know in chanting is known by heart and not because I know the theory. This means I know the tones from Mount Angel and I use those to chant the psalms.

BTW: I've started using the Latin version of 1979. I'm going to print off two copies for C and I on nice vellum and bind them. I notice I slow down in the Latin, and I suspect the language of the 1928 BCP would do the same. 1979 English is quick to rush through for me, modern German renditions are the same for C. This is just right for the both of us to be brought before "I AM".

 
At Wednesday, November 02, 2005 7:08:00 PM, Blogger Derek the Ænglican said...

I've often thought of doing something like that, Chrstopher... The closest I've come is a set of extracts from the Liber Usualis.

Some of your recent comments have prompted this question...is there a synoptic edition of the early prayer books that quickly and easily lays out the differences between them? I don't know these works--at all, really--and I know my brain could grasp them best with a prayer book version of the Quattor Evangeliorium

 
At Thursday, November 03, 2005 6:28:00 AM, Blogger Charlotte said...

Great post, but I will now wait a little more before putting "Chanting for Absolute Beginners" up :)

 
At Friday, November 04, 2005 8:45:00 PM, Blogger LutheranChik said...

The Rev. Cynthia Bourgeault's audio course in singing the Psalter, Singing the Psalms, is a good, basic resource, especially for musically untrained people who'd still like to chant the Psalms. She gets into the topic of breathing as well, which was new for me.

(Am I ready for prime time? Um...no...but I'm motivated by the fact that we no longer include the Psalm in our Sunday service. Oy. I'd like to be able to one day leverage an ability to chant them into an offer to resurrect their use on Sunday mornings. ("Can we? Can we? I'll lead!")

"Guard Us Sleeping" is a great recording.

 
At Tuesday, November 08, 2005 7:20:00 PM, Blogger Monk-in-Training said...

Are sound files of the Psalms on line somewhere?

 
At Wednesday, November 09, 2005 2:52:00 PM, Blogger bls said...

That's the question, MiT. I'm trying to find some for this purpose, but if I can't, I want to actually record some Psalm singing and put those files up.

 
At Sunday, November 27, 2005 12:31:00 PM, Blogger bls said...

The best thing is, I was recently able to explain the "breath meditation" thing to a whole retreat-house full of guests attending Lauds for the first time. It made perfect sense to them.

See? We should all teach classes in this in our local parishes.

 
At Monday, November 28, 2005 6:56:00 PM, Blogger Derek the Ænglican said...

Very cool!

 
At Thursday, April 20, 2006 7:18:00 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

Although not BCP, the Lutheran Liturgical Prayer Brotherhood's website has page where there are the complete psalms (KJV) in traditional Gregorian tones--the files are in MP3 format.
Enjoy!
http://www.llpb.us/Canticles-Psalms-Ants.htm

 
At Monday, July 17, 2006 2:31:00 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

What makes me absolutely insane is that I can't find a decent psalter that has the psalm tones in them.

Let's see, not the BCP.
Not Celebrating Common Worship.
Not the Grail Inclusive Language Psalter.
Not the Grail Singing Version (mine only has the pointing, not the Gelineau tones).

WORSHIP by GIA Pub. doesn't have all 150 psalms.
The Anglican Chant Psalter is way too hard to use for individual use.
So is the Plainsong Psalter.
The UMC Hymnal has 8 tones, but doesn't tell which psalms they go with, and you'd have to keep flipping in order to do it anyway. And it doesn't have all 150 psalms.

Monasteries write their own psalters and don't give them out.

It just shouldn't be this hard!!

 
At Tuesday, July 18, 2006 8:53:00 AM, Blogger bls said...

Why do you find the Plainsong Psalter to be too hard, Anon? Is it the Gregorian notation?

Do you know about the St. Dunstan's Plainsong Psalter? It seems quite easy to use, at least to me, but you do have to know the notation. And you have to be willing to use the old versions of the Psalms.

 
At Tuesday, July 18, 2006 8:59:00 AM, Blogger bls said...

(I would really like to write all this stuff down, though - including Derek's methods described here - into some sort of book for general use.

Wouldn't that be great?)

 
At Wednesday, July 19, 2006 11:46:00 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

I think that the plainsong psalter is too hard because the chant notation itself is too hard (and I'm not a good enough singer). Between the accent, the slash and the dots, it gets too confusing.

Take, for example, psalm 25. I can deal with the intonation. The reciting note is fine, but then the mediant has not just one accent, but two, and each accent has optional notes. Then, in the second half, you have the reciting note, that slash, then an accent, and two sets of dots. I find it very confusing. I spend more time trying to figure out how I'm supposed to chant the psalm, than just chanting.

What I would prefer would be just one accent per half (basically starting on the last 3 syllables, depending on how it works out). I've visited 3 different monasteries, and they all do it that way, and it sounds great, and I can chant it with ease, but they've all written their own materials that they don't give out.

Yes, I have St. Dunstan's Psalter too. It isn't any easier, plus it has the added difficulty of being old english. I can't sing words like "thee", "thou", "leadeth" and "whoso privily slandereth his neighbor" without feeling, well, like a fool.

As for books, there are a few out there, some of which I've read, and some I haven't. "Chant Made Simple" is a horrid book. I've read a few things on beliefnet by Cynthia Bourgeault that are good, but I haven't read her book on the chant yet. There's a few other online resources that are decent. I haven't found any audio (midi or mp3 or whatever) files on psalm tones yet, however. And I've looked. The UMC website has about a dozen on their site in scorch format, but not all 150.

Cheers

u.

 
At Wednesday, July 19, 2006 12:08:00 PM, Blogger Derek the Ænglican said...

Hey u.,

Chant notation can be difficult to get a handle one when you start out. I had the benefit of an in-the-flesh teacher and a class of fellow-learners; I can imagine the difficulties of trying to figure it out on your own with the help...

Yes, the Early Modern English of the "Coverdale" version in the St Dunstan's takes some getting used to. I prefer it myself, but totally understand that it's not accessible for everyone.

I've also had a hard time finding decent resources. I'd love to see a book that had:

* Clear forthright instructions including examples that could be listened to/sung along with from an attached cd with both regular cd files and mp3 files.
* A pointed BCP psalter
* Some excerpts of particularly pertinent documents on chant from both modern andmedieval sources.

I think bls should get started on it immediately... ;-)

 
At Friday, July 21, 2006 7:26:00 AM, Blogger bls said...

U -

Try the Lutheran Liturgical Prayer Brotherhood link that the previous Anon posted. All 150 Psalms are there, in mp3 format - albeit sung by only one person, so to me the effect isn't as good. And of course each Psalm is only sung to one tone at most.

Also, get Guard Us Sleeping, a recorded service of Compline by the SSJE in Boston. They sing the night psalms to Tone 8, just as they are notated in the St. Dunstan's. You can follow along and see what one tone is about, at least. It's always the same system, so at least you can become familiar with how to translate what's written on the page to what you hear.

 
At Saturday, August 19, 2006 7:14:00 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

Been a while since I've been on.

Yes, I have Guard Us Sleeping. I also have (the now out of print) Singing the Daily Office, also by SSJE, which is a great resource. I also used to listen to Compline each week online from the Minnesota Compline choir, although they stopped airing some time in May for the summer. I also have audio services of Compline (my favorite office) from the "Feathers of Green Gold" Compline choir, Abbey of the Solesmes in Latin, "Calming the Storm" from Glenstal Abbey, and a few others. Compline really is the only office that I'm comfortable chanting the whole way through.

Thanks for the link to those .MP3s. Does anyone know what translation of the psalms they are using? I thought that since they are called "Lutheran", that it would be the LBW version, but it isn't. Kinda hard to follow along if I don't know the words!

U.

 
At Monday, August 21, 2006 7:23:00 AM, Blogger Derek the Ænglican said...

Thy're Lutheran but their Missouri Synod--I believe the version is KJV.

 
At Saturday, October 13, 2007 3:18:00 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

The Lutheran psalms is beautiful - just what I was wanting, just voice no musical accompanyment but...

I live in Australia and we have the Grail translation of the psalms. Do you know of an equivalent of the Lutheran psalms with Grail words?

Sharon

 

Post a Comment

<< Home